MESSAGE
| DATE | 2020-04-11 |
| FROM | Ruben Safir
|
| SUBJECT | Subject: [Hangout - NYLXS] New Yoawk is dead
|
Why the classic Noo Yawk accent is fading away
By Sheila McClear
February 6, 2010 | 7:25pm
The first thing theatergoers will notice about the revival of “A View of
the Bridge,” Arthur Miller’s 1950s drama about a working-class
Italian-American family in Red Hook, is that the characters are speaking
a different language: Brooklynese. You got a problem with that!?
You can hear the mellifluous — some might say grating — dialect being
celebrated on Broadway by Scarlett Johansson and Liev Schreiber. But
that may be the only place. Linguists say features of the classic accent
are heard less and less in the city itself, especially among the younger
generation. Mocked and stereotyped, the long o’s and w’s have fallen out
of favor, unless you’re auditioning for a mob film.
Will old Noo Yawk become a museum piece, the subway token of language?
*
First, a lesson in rhoticity. What, exactly, is the New York accent? One
key component, linguists say, is the “R.” Not only do New Yorkers drop
Rs (call the doctah!), they add them in where they’re not needed,
usually when the next word starts with a vowel, which creates “I sawr it
with my very own eyes!” and “The sofer in the living room is green.” It
all started across the pond. The New York accent, with its dropped Rs,
is “absolutely from British English,” says Kara Becker, a Ph.D. student
at NYU who is writing her dissertation on New York City English.
Londoners began to drop Rs around the end of the 1600s, according to
Michael Newman, associate professor of lingusitics at Queens College.
The East Coast is referred to as the “R-less corridor” by linguists, and
other coastal cities have accents with features in common with New York,
like Boston and Charleston, S.C. Those cities “were settled around the
same time, and the speakers came from a certain place” — South London —
“using a certain type of British English,” Becker says.
Stephen Gabis, the dialect coach for “A View From the Bridge,” says New
York speech gradually got “a little slower, a bit lazier, and the
muscularity was relaxed,” becoming less stiff and leaning toward the
heavier “ga’head” (translation: “go ahead”).
Up until 1945, it was considered distinguished to drop your Rs. Think of
FDR, on his radio addresses: “We have nothing to feee-ah but fe-ah
istelf.” After World War II, “Americans stopped considering British
English to be quite so prestigious,” says Becker. “Broadcaster English”
became the new desired norm.
Then there’s the curious case of the New York Honk, which Tom Wolfe
wrote about in 1976. The Honk was a certain upper-class East Coast
accent that persisted after WWII, spoken by wealthy prep-school types
such as Bobby Kennedy and Nelson Rockefeller. Wolf called it “derived in
the natural Anglophile bias of Eastern social life.” The unique way that
New Yorkers draw out their vowels is another important feature of the
dialect. Raising the vowels is one of the first exercises Gabis does
with actors learning the accent.
New York-style vowels are diphthongs — meaning they change into another
sound during pronunciation. That’s just a boring way to describe the
musical “aww-uhh” that New Yorkers bring to their vowels, pulling them
apart like taffy, turning “sausage” into “sawww-sage.” Words like “talk”
and “walk” turn into two-syllable words: “Taww-uhk” and “waww-uuhk.”
Travis Bickle’s famous line from “Taxi Driver” actually sounds more
like, “Yoo tawwhkin’ ta may?”
Where do these diphthongs come from? There’s no obvious answer. They’ve
popped up since the 1600s in both England and America, perhaps just
local dialects that developed independently.
More apparent is the lineage of “dese” and “dose.” The only immigrant
language that had the “th” sound in it was Greek, meaning all the other
travellers to the New World had a hard time pronouncing the sound — in
other words, they had trouble wid it.
And the rest of the country pronounces a word like “singer” as
“seeeng-er,” with a soft “g.” But in the New York dialect, it’s
“SING-er.” That pronounced ‘g’ is a vestige of Yiddish and Italian.
Nobody’s quite sure when these features melded into the accent we know
today, though it shows up on some of the earliest sound recordings.
After the British, the next generation of European immigrants to New
York City — Irish and Germans in the mid-1800s, Jews, Eastern Europeans,
Russians, and Italians starting in the 1880s — contributed their own
features. There were references to a “Bowery accent” by the turn of the
century.
How and why dialects change is mysterious, influenced by a constellation
of factors, and not even linguists can say for sure how it works. “Once
you leave them alone, they just develop and change, like Latin became
Italian, French and Portugese. [A dialect] develops its own
peculiarities,” says George Jochnowitz, retired Professor Emeritus of
Linguistics at the College of Staten Island.
But that old story that you could tell by someone’s accent the street
they grew up on is an urban myth. Whether Brooklyn or The Bronx, New
Yorkese is all the same accent.
“What people think of as borough differences are actually socioeconomic
differences, like education, income level and occupation,” Newman says.
“No one has ever shown any geographical difference between any of the
regions in the city.”
“It’s borough pride [in thinking] they talk differently from the rest,”
Gabis adds. Born in Brooklyn of Irish and Lithuanian descent, the
accents in the play were inspired by the voices he grew up around: “It
sounded like a Scorsese movie.”
There are, however, slight ethnic differences between accents. The
Carbone family in Miller’s play is Italian-American, and “the Italian
version [of the New York accent] is so musical,” Gabis says, noting that
their unique cadence is consistent with Italian. “The accents migrated,
and a couple generations later, the music is still there.” Think of the
up-and-down inflections of Joe Pesci in “Raging Bull”: “Fuggedaboutit, I
ain’t doin’ it, I ain’t hittin’ ya!”
Then there’s the Irish version, “the Jimmy Cagney way of speaking — real
machine gun, like your mouth is a weapon,” Gabis says. “You doity rat!“
Neighborhood homogeneity plays a part in developing an accent, which
happens between the ages 8 and 14. “Back then, it was the purity of that
neighborhood, so you spoke like the people in your little world,” said
Jessica Hecht, the Connecticut-born actress who plays Beatrice in
“Bridge.” “You didn’t have any other influence.”
*
Population change is one major factor of the New York accent’s decline,
as the mixing of different people tends to neutralize accents. Why
exactly hasn’t been figured out by linguists: “There’s a huge argument
in the field as to whether it’s changed by contact with other people or
by self-identity,” Newman says.
In other words, do kids neglect to pick up the accent that their parents
have because not as many people around them have it — or in the
self-identity argument, do they become self-conscious about the accent
and not want to talk like their parents and grandparents?
Much will be learned from Kara Becker’s field site — the blocks where
she studies and records denizens’ speech — on the Lower East Side. It is
the same area that the “godfather of sociolinguistics” William Labov
studied when he created “The Atlas of American English” in 1966.
The area had not been examined by linguists since, and Becker has spent
the last two years recording and analyzing the speech patterns of 64
people. What she found: Young people native to the neighborhood aren’t
developing the accent Labov heard.
“On the Lower East Side in particular, the people we would expect to
maintain the New York accent — those of European ancestry, Italian,
Irish — the young folks of those enthnicities are not using the New York
features,” Becker says. “Older speakers [still] have the classic accent,
among white people.”
Becker’s group is contained within the Lower East Side, which has seen a
huge population shift during its gentrification of the last 20 years.
But in general, “New Yorkers are more and more ‘R’-ful, and the amount
of R-dropping is decreasing,” Newman says. “We don’t really know why.”
“In Manhattan [the accent] is definitely dying,” Jochnowitz says.
Manhattan has also seen the most influx of new people from outside the
state, who don’t usually pick up an accent. The dialect “remains mostly
in the outer boroughs, and is most alive in Staten Island.”
Staten Island is a known stronghold of New York talk not only because it
has the most stable New York population, but because “anywhere you have
lots of white people — Jews and Italians and Irish and Germans — whose
origins are in the city, you’re going to find that accent pretty
systematically,” Newman says. Its relative isolation may have also helped.
As the accent is dying in some places, it’s migrated to others. New
Yorkers have brought their accents with them to Long Island — also known
as Lawn Guyland — or New Joisey (hello, cast of “Jersey Shore”!)
Although George Bernard Shaw thought the New York dialect was the most
beautiful sound in the world — “the ultimate in sophistication in human
speech” — not everyone is in love with the accent, mostly because it
signifies working-class origins. To graduate from Queens College in the
1960s, students had to pass a speech test — and you would do well to
pronounce your Rs.
Because of the accent’s humbler origins, generations of parents hoping
their children would grow up to be doctors or lawyers and get out of
“the neighborhood” encouraged their children to leave it behind, deeming
is lower class, ethnic or crude.
Some parts of the accent have simply gone extinct already for that very
reason. No one asks to meet you on the corner of “Thoity Thoid and Thoid
Street” anymore, or declares that “the oily boid gets the woim” — that
particular feature has been gone for “50, 60, 70 years,” Jochnowitz
says. It was “laughed out of the dialect” — stigmatized so much that
people were shamed into cutting it out.
The same thing is happening now to the “yuhs guys” and “sawr it.”
“If people try to lose [their accent], they’re more likely to lose it if
they feel they’re not going to get ahead in life with it,” Jochnowitz
adds, although he mentioned that a good number of educated people hang
on to their accents, though sometimes a bit self-consciously. Ed Koch,
himself an unrepetent R-dropper, once went so far as to say he wouldn’t
mourn Brooklynese if it disappeared.
Despite the unfair class bias, there are just as many who see the talk
as an integral part of the city’s identity. “I’m very saddened by the
idea of losing [their accent] permanently,” Gabis says. “I never met an
accent I didn’t like.”
While it’s true that the younger generation has moved away from New York
dialect, that “doesn’t mean that there aren’t plenty of people embracing
and using the accent, because they have strong associations and pride
about being New Yorkers,” Becker says. “The short answer is no, it’s not
dying, it’s changing.”
There’s something to be said for the dyed-in-the-wool New Yorker, for
whom Brooklyn or Queens is an attitude, not a place.
“Language is meant to shift around,” Gabis says. “I think it’s alive and
well, depending on the neighborhoods you go to.” But you might have to
look — and listen — a little harder for it.
Freelance writer Sheila McClear’s book, “The Last of the Live Nude
Girls” (Soft Skull), will be published next year.
--
So many immigrant groups have swept through our town
that Brooklyn, like Atlantis, reaches mythological
proportions in the mind of the world - RI Safir 1998
http://www.mrbrklyn.com
DRM is THEFT - We are the STAKEHOLDERS - RI Safir 2002
http://www.nylxs.com - Leadership Development in Free Software
http://www.brooklyn-living.com
Being so tracked is for FARM ANIMALS and extermination camps,
but incompatible with living as a free human being. -RI Safir 2013
_______________________________________________
Hangout mailing list
Hangout-at-nylxs.com
http://lists.mrbrklyn.com/mailman/listinfo/hangout
|
|
